WidgetGap

Got an ADA website demand letter? What to do in the first week

Updated November 14, 2026 · Not legal advice

Don't ignore it and don't pay it on the spot. Call an attorney who handles ADA website claims, check your insurance, keep every record, and find out what actually fails on your site so you know which claims hold up. This isn't legal advice; your attorney leads, and the steps below help you get ready to talk to them.

First, what a demand letter is

A demand letter is a lawyer's written claim, sent before a lawsuit, saying your website shuts out people with disabilities. It usually lists barriers it found, asks for a settlement payment and a promise to fix the site, and sets a deadline. It isn't a court ruling, but it shouldn't be brushed off: ignoring it is how these turn into filed lawsuits.1

Your first-week checklist

  1. Write down the deadline. Most letters give you a few weeks. Put it on the calendar today.
  2. Call an attorney who handles ADA website claims. A general business lawyer can help, but someone who sees these every week will know the firm that sent yours and what a reasonable outcome looks like.
  3. Check your insurance. Some business and cyber policies cover these claims, and many require you to notify the insurer quickly.2
  4. Keep everything. Save the letter, the envelope, emails and any record of past accessibility work, including invoices for your overlay if you have one.
  5. Ask your attorney before changing the site. Fixing problems is the goal, but how and when you do it can matter to your case. Advice varies, so follow your attorney's lead.3
  6. Find out what actually fails. Get an audit of the pages the letter mentions, plus your cart and checkout. That tells you and your attorney which claims are real, which are boilerplate, and how big the fix is.
  7. Make a dated remediation plan. A written plan with dates and a published accessibility statement are often part of how these get resolved.

What these letters usually cite

Most cite the same handful of automated findings: images with no description, form fields with no label, low-contrast text, links and buttons with no readable name, and parts of the site you can't reach with a keyboard. They're also the failures our audit lists first, with the exact page and element.

What not to do

Know what's real before you call your attorney

Start with a free risk check of your homepage to see how exposed you are, then get the full audit of the pages the letter mentions. You'll have a fix list your developer can start on and a dated plan to share with your attorney.

Get my free scan

Common questions

How much do ADA website demand letters ask for?

It varies widely by firm, state and business size. Typical small-business matters settle for $5,000 to $20,000, and some demand letters resolve for $1,500 to $5,000, before legal fees and the cost of fixes. Your attorney can tell you what's typical for the firm that sent yours.

Can a business outside New York or California get one?

Yes. Online stores are often sued where their customers are, not where the business is. New York, Florida and Illinois see the most federal filings.

How fast can I get an audit?

Our Instant Audit arrives within the hour. The Verified Audit, which adds a person testing your key journeys by hand, arrives within 3 business days. Both include a developer fix list and a dated remediation plan.

Sources

  1. Bureau of Internet Accessibility, "Steps to Take After Receiving an ADA Website Demand Letter," boia.org.
  2. Clym, "What to Do After Receiving a Website Demand Letter," clym.io.
  3. Practitioner guidance differs on timing of site changes; for example TestParty's Shopify demand-letter guide advises waiting for counsel before editing the site.